Irene Silver has a problem with her cauldron. The last girl she tried to boil in it escaped and broke it on the way out. Irene calls the maintenance superintendent to come fix her cauldron, but Bob the Super is busy and sends his friend Paula Diamonds, to fix it. The unenthusiastic college girl happens to be home for spring break and is helping her dad. Irene starts to realize that she will solve two problems tonight; a broken cauldron and who to have for dinner.